|
African Health Sciences
Makerere University Medical School
ISSN: 1680-6905 EISSN: 1729-0503
Vol. 8, Num. s1, 2008, pp. S37-S38
|
Untitled1
African Health Sciences, Vol. 8, Suppl, 2008, pp. S37-S38
Civil courage: Good people in an evil time, building and
promoting resilience
Svetlana Broz
Garden of the Righteous Worldwide (GARIWO), Sarajevo http://gariwo.net/eng/ethnic_c/garden.htm
Correspondence: Svetlana Broz, Tinohovska 27, 71240 Hadzici, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Phone:+387 33 428 210, Cell.+387 61 170 897 Fax: +387 33 428 211 www.gariwo.org , www.svetlanabroz.org skype: svetlanabroz
Code Number: hs08063
From the perspective of the continuing relevance
of studying the efforts directed towards rebuilding
a resilient community in the former Yugoslavia, and
more specifically, Bosnia and Herzegovina, the experiences
of a local non-governmental and non-profit
organization are both valuable and relevant. Eleven years after
the violence was ended by international intervention,
the region still suffers many serious social ills. Life
is incomparably more difficult now than at the
outbreak of the war fifteen years ago. Despite the tragic fact
that the violence was politically initiated and
orchestrated, reconstruction efforts have often been designed
along ethnic-nationalist distinctions, thus further
engraving lines of social division between people.
Social incoherence did not lead to the violence. But, it
has become one of the tragic consequences of the war,
the peace agreement that divided the country along
ethnic-nationalist lines by constitution, and, to some extent,
of many efforts for resilience and reconciliation.
As a result, large scale activities aiming
for resilience have perhaps left the region less resilient
than it was. What does this mean for the understanding of
a resilient community and what can the experiences of
a practitioner/an NGO contribute?
Civil courage: Good people in an evil time
Refusing to believe that nothing human existed
amidst all the madness of war in Bosnia and Herzegovina
and that society was destructing itself from within, I
searched for the humanity behind the headlines. I started going
to the war zones in January 1993initially as a
cardiologist determined to help at least one person lacking
proper medical care because of the war.
But while providing care for the people of
three major ethno-national backgroundsdistinguished as Catholic Croats, Muslim Bosniaks, and Eastern Orthodox Christian Serbs by nationalist
politiciansI felt their need to open their souls and talk as
human beings, without being judged about their fates in
the war. From their short, spontaneous confessions in
the cardiology ward, I understood their need for
truth, which in places where bombs were actually falling,
was surprisingly nuanced and refined compared to
the dominant much more simplistic pictures of the
Bosnian war zone.
I was told stories of individuals in Bosnia
and Herzegovina who had the courage to stand up to
crimes being committed against the innocent, even when
they had no weapons to help them. These people served
as genuine examples of the goodness, compassion, humanity, and civil courage that continued to exist
in these times of evil. They broke free from the identity
of the bystander, that person who chooses to look away,
to ignore, and to silently accept the suffering of
others. Instead, these human beings provided
compelling examples of upstanders, people who stick to their
moral convictions and norms, and demonstrate great
civil courage through their acts, even in a situation as
horrific as the Bosnian war. My book Good People in an Evil
Time is a collection of 90 first-hand testimonies from
people who survived the war, illustrating the ways in
which anonymous people were upstanders.
Some people may dismiss these
stories, believing that wartime examples of violent
behavior reveal far more about human nature. I disagree. We
must pay careful attention to these stories, because they
hold up a mirror and require us to reflect on our own
acts and behavior. They clearly demonstrate the
possibility of choice, even in the most trying circumstances.
When shared, these stories can therefore encourage
more people to stand up and speak out against evil, and to
act in accordance with their moral norms. The hundreds
of interviews I've conducted, and the reactions from
the tens of thousands of people with whom I have
shared these stories, have repeatedly confirmed this
idea. Indeed, I've found that imparting upstanders'
actions can have the very real and enduring effect of
inspiring others to follow their example.
These examples of individual human resilience affecting the human community where
external assistance was absent, have led me to found
NGO GARIWO in Sarajevo. Its purpose is to teach
young people about the individual's capacity to protect
people of other faiths and ethnicities from crimes
against humanity. It educates young people about the
multiple acts of both kindness and courage that many
people selflessly performed during the tragedy that
befell Yugoslavia little more than a decade ago. Learning
about those who stood up against mass hatred and atrocities
in the worst of circumstances serves
reconciliatory purposes, because it demonstrates the goodness
of individual human beings and not the evil of
socially constructed groups. Moreover, it helps the current
youth here realize that they too have a choice. Either they
keep quiet and accept things the way they are, or they
decide to defy immorality and injustice for a better future.
The effects of the war that ended just
over eleven years ago continue and social destruction
will persist if not countered. Intolerance, ethnic division
and impunity inspire hatred, fear and mistrust and
impede the country's progress and development. This is
why the primary focus of our program is to help people
look forward, not back. Learning about civil courage
inspires people to act. GARIWO therefore conjoins educational with civic activities in order to stimulate civil
courage and enhance its effects. Its regional network of
young leaders is continuously expanding and providing
ever greater opportunities for (international) collaboration.
How does this contribute to the
development of a Resilience Index?
The focus on good people, rather than on
victims, perpetrators and ethnic-nationalist groups,
aids confidence, social action and collaboration. As a
result, raised awareness about individual, human, civil
courage can be fostered. This builds resilience. Every act of
civil courage serves as an example that restores faith
in humanity and opens perspectives for social
coexistence. In the end, all real positive changes in Bosnia
and Herzegovina, and elsewhere, will depend on the individual who lives up to his responsibility to act
against prejudice, bigotry, inhumanity and violence. This is
the subject of civil courage, which is relevant not only
in public emergency situations but also - of
greater immediate relevance - in the moral challenges
of everyday work and social life. It is also how, I
believe, NGO GARIWO's objectives of and the testimonies
of good people in an evil time can contribute to
defining resilience, understanding the resilient community,
and the development of a resilience index.
© Copyright 2008 - Makerere Medical School, Uganda
|