|
East and Central African Journal of Surgery, Vol. 15, No. 1, Mar-Apr, 2010, pp. 22-27 Knowledge and Practice of Breast Self Examination among Female Students in a Sub Saharan African UniversityObaikol R, Galukande M, Fualal J Department
of Surgery, Mulago Hospital – Kampala, Uganda Code Number: js10004 Background: Breast cancer is the most common cancer among women in many parts of Africa.
Facilities for screening and early detection are extremely limited yet early
diagnosis improves survival. This study explored the practice of Breast Self
Examination among female university students as a means of screening and early
detection in a low resources environment. Introduction Breast cancer is the most common cancer among women is many parts of Africa and a lead cause of cancer mortality in African women1. The incidence in Uganda is rapidly raising2, though mass screening with use of mammography has been effective in the more affluent countries, it is not readily available to most of the women in Sub Saharan Africa3,4 . The peak of Breast Cancer in a recent Ugandan study5 is in the 3rd decade of life, therefore necessitating mass screening and awareness campaigns among younger women than the model in western countries. Mammogram guidelines indicate that a mammogram is appropriate only in women above 35 years old6 due to breast density in the younger women making visualization of present lesions and interpretation difficult and therefore unreliable.The available options left are ultrasound scan and Breast Self Examinations (BSE). Breast Self Examination is appealing as a routine screening method because the examination has no financial cost (apart from the initial instruction sessions) and can be conducted in private7. Most studies on the effectiveness of BSE have been observational. They suggest that these women are more likely to find their breast tumour themselves, that the tumours tend to be smaller and that these women have an increased survival8,9 . This study investigated the knowledge, frequency and quality of practice of Breast Self Examination among university female students. Methods A cross sectional study carried out at Makerere University an 80-year-old institution over a 10-day period. A call was made for students to participate. Participants were enrolled consecutively until the minimum required sample size was reached. Participants were residents in designated halls of residence. A total of 1400 students were on the residents register on the camps. 320 volunteer participants were interviewed using a pretested standardized questionnaire and were physically examined, for possible breast pathology including lumps, nipple discharge and any other related pathologies. In the interview sessions the participants were asked to demonstrate how they normally examine their breasts (if they did) before the investigator. Variables in the questionnaires included demographics, frequency on Breast Self Examination, timing, consistency, action taken when an abnormality was thought to be found and the interval between noticing and taking action especially in consulting a health professional and what type of professional. The reasons for delay were solicited. For data entry and analysis STATA 8.2 package was used. Proportions were compared using Fischer’s exact test. Consent was sought from all the participants; Institutional Review Board approval was sought prior to carrying out the study. Results The data was collected over a period of 10 days in the month of April 2009. A total of 320 participants were recruited and due to recording errors, analysis was carried out on the results of 314 of them. Table 1 sumarizes the demographic character of the study population. Their mean age was 21.9 years with 83.4% being in the 21-25 years age group. Also see Table 2 and Table 3. *The two participants who took time between finding the breast lump and seeking help spent 1 month and 2 years. The reasons where that one was scared and the other thought it was a ‘normal’ finding. Discussion This study involved university students, the demographics are what was anticipated. The mean age was in the early twenties. Most were nulliparous and most of them being ‘direct’ university entrants, they were not expected to have started families. The district of residence and ethnicity is a general reflection of who may have access to tertiary education in the country and reflection of the dominant ethnic groupings in terms of numbers. The Ganda and Nkole contribute close to 45% of the general population12. Practice of BSE In this study, the level of awareness was high; but the knowledge of the technique and practice ratios was poor. The knowledge awareness of BSE was over 80% similar to figures cited in other studies such as by Demirkiran in 2007 performed among Turkey nurses. It is important that the awareness of BSE translates into adequate or appropriate practice early detection of breast lumps. Most cancerous breast lumps are self discovered, but it is important that these lumps are discovered in the early stages when they are still small. Tumors detected at 2cm in diameter allow women more treatment choices and a greater chance of long-term survival13 . In this study, lump sizes ranged from 2.4cm to 3.4 cm on average. They were smaller (2.4cm) for those who has lumps but were not aware of them and had not practiced BSE, and they averaged 3.4cm for those that were aware, they had the lumps. Is it possible that correctly performed BSE (correct technique and regular and timing could pick lumps less than 3.4 cm in our context?. Breast Self Examination should be practiced correctly and this involves a number of aspects; frequency, timing, a correct technique consistent application of it as well as acting on any positive findings without much delay. In published work, women who practice BSE tend to be younger, pre menopausal and of a higher socio economic status14,15 . Possibly this has to do with access and exposure to health talk information through the media, peers and health workers. This description agrees with the demographics of this study even though, selection of this study population was self fulfilling. Role of university graduates in society University students are thought to be the more enlightened and empowered lot living in an area with good geographical access to health care facilities. The less empowered and less exposed rural women face a lot more barriers to not only seeking professional attention but also access to knowledge of Breast Self Examination. The lack of empowerment and the subsequent missed opportunities for early detection is owed to lack of information, knowledge and opportunities for screening. Yet BSE is considered a reliable self screening tool for early detection of Breast cancer in less privileged communities11. Utility and efficacy Whereas, in the Sub Saharan Africa there is limited resource for health care including Human Resources for Health, most resources are dedicated to infectious diseases such as HIV/AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis, this creates a scenario of neglect of surgical conditions in which Breast Cancer would fall for that matter. It is imperative therefore that we heighten awareness of breast cancer and better still advocate for use of low cost interventions, but also investigate the efficacy of these low cost interventions. Delay In this study, only two women had self discovered lumps; one took a month before seeking professional help. In some of the literature reviewed, it is not a significant delay. The second sought help after 2 years. This is considered a significant delay16 . The reasons cited for delay; the first was scared and the second thought it was normal to have a lump in the breast. Factors that influence seeking help for women that self discover lumps range from sociodemographics (age) to women’s knowledge and beliefs, social and psychological factors, health service issues, health seeking habits, among others17,18 . Owing
to the small numbers in this study, we may not make strong inferences as to
what reasons would prevent Ugandan young females from seeking help for self
discovered lumps but these findings give us an idea and are similar reasons to
those found elsewhere17, Conclusion The
level of awareness of BSE was high but the knowledge and practice ratios were
poor, we therefore An optional moduleon female health education that includes Breast health should be introduced at the universities possibly in the first year of study, in resource limited environments. References
Copyright © 2010 - East and Central African Journal of Surgery The following images related to this document are available:Photo images[js10004t3.jpg] [js10004t2.jpg] [js10004t1.jpg] |
|